29 May 2024

I was recently called upon to do jury service after dodging it for years. In truth I wasn't really looking forward to it. We were given very little preparation beforehand and didn't even find out what the trial was about until we arrived on the first day.

The case was kind of surreal in that it raised such mixed feelings in all of us. I don't think I'm misrepresenting anyone to say, most of all for the women of the jury. The trial was of the gang rape of a young girl which was witnessed by her boyfriend. The girl was called Avery Apshaw and her boyfriend, Danny Whitelaw. We were all shocked and confused at what unfolded as the story was told.

It was an already harrowing story, made worse I'm sure, by her knowing her boyfriend was made to watch much of the whole assault. The case started and we heard evidence from Avery that she'd been home with her boyfriend while her parents were away for the weekend.

She described how there was a ring at the doorbell and Danny had gone to answer it. When he returned he was accompanied by the 12 accused men, one of them holding a knife to his throat. They forced him to sit on a chair and used cable ties to tie him to it.

Avery said she was so scared that they were going to kill him that she was unable to do anything; she just froze. The leader of the gang, a big man called Mike, made her strip naked in front of them while some of the other members apparently ransacked the house.

She described how one of the gang members held her arms behind her back while the others groped and touched her body as her boyfriend was forced to watch. After a while they took her into her parents' bedroom and dragged her boyfriend in shortly after.

She tearfully told the court that they then held her down on her parents bed and took turns with her, repeatedly raping her over the whole weekend, much of it while her boyfriend was forced to watch.

Around this point the defence came out with what they said was new evidence and they produced video recordings of the assault. It seems that the gang had set up several video cameras in her parents' bedroom which Avery had failed to notice.

The gang members claimed that the sex with her was planned by her and her boyfriend; a gang bang that was entirely consensual and that the videos proved that she wanted it.

This is the transcript taken from our viewing of one of the videos taken by the rapist's and shown to the members of the jury during their trial. I have secretly recorded the sound. As it would have been impossible to get a copy of the video I will describe the scene as best I can. This was the first of the many videos they took recording much of the 2 days of her rape;

Avery is a stunningly beautiful young girl, sweet and innocent looking with a very slim and willowy figure. Hardly surprisingly, given today's fashion, her pussy was completely hairless; so smooth that I can only assume she must have had it very recently waxed.

Despite her diminutive size she was putting up quite a struggle. But she clearly was no match for the 8 young men. They simply tightened their grip on her, forcing her legs ever wider apart revealing her little pink slit, which peeled open slightly as they held her legs so wide apart. With the flexibility of her youth she seemed to suffer no discomfort despite the fact that her legs were splayed extremely wide apart, clearly presenting her pussy for them all to see!

"What have you brought us, Danny boy? Little Miss tiny tits!" Said the guy called Mike, who seemed to be the leader of the gang, obviously addressing her boyfriend. She might have been small but her tits were firm and nicely rounded, jiggling slightly as she struggled.

It struck me at the time as a little strange that they seemed to know his name. But those thoughts didn't last long as I'm afraid I was too engrossed in what I was seeing to ponder too long.

"No! Why are you doing this? Please? Stop!" She could be heard crying.

"Quit struggling you dirty little slut, just relax and enjoy it. See what Mike's got for you!" Taunted one of the men, to the cruel laughter of the rest of them.

The video showed Mike between her legs, dropping his jeans to reveal the most terrifyingly large penis I've ever seen. It was already stiffly erect and easily 8 inches long. But it was mostly the thickness that made it so terrifying; it was absolutely immense. The poor young girl was forced to look at the fleshy monstrosity as he made ready to fuck her with it.

"No!" She cried, "Please? I can't! Don't do this? No!"

It seemed like no coincidence that her little pink pussy lips further peeled open to reveal the glistening wet interior just as he was aiming the fearsome weapon at her little cunt! Despite her struggles it just seemed like her pussy was opening, as if preparing itself to welcome him in.

"Go on, give it to her Mike, she's gagging for it!" The man identified as Lawrence said, as the others just laughed at the look of terror on her face.

*No! No! Oh please? Oh no please? No!" Avery cried.

"Let her have it Mike, she's going to love it!" Said another of them.

"It can't fit in, please? it's much too big!" She whimpered.

"Shut up bitch, you're gonna love it when he's got that huge fucker up you!" Said Lawrence.

"No! You're going to really hurt me! Please don't do this?" She begged.

"I can't do it, I can't do it! There's no way! Oh God, it's way too big for me!" She whimpered.

"Aow! Aow! Aow!" She cried as the huge head of his penis began to enter her, spreading the glistening wet lips of her pussy apart. Although he'd wetted the head of his cock with saliva it hardly seemed necessary.

"Oh my God! Oh my God! Oh my God!" She whimpered in panic.

"Take it out, take it out! Please take it out? Please take it out? Please? Aow! Ow!" She cried.

"It doesn't fit! No! It can't fit. It can't fit. It's too big! Fuck, no!" She cried in panic as more and more if his cock was being wedged inside her. By now the massive great head of the thing was completely inside her but the even thicker shaft was meeting some resistance.

"Open your fucking cunt for me bitch!" Growled Mike impatiently. "Let me in! Fucking let me in!"

"I can't! It hurts, it hurts. Fuck it hurts!" She wailed. "Please take it out? Please take it out of my pussy? Oh, no, oh! Ohhh!"

But as he withdrew a little before ramming himself even deeper, curiously his cock was very obviously glistening with her wetness.

I don't think any of us on the jury were in any doubt that a cock as enormous as that would be causing her pain, but evidently not enough to stop her getting aroused by it!

"You're stretching me out! You're stretching my pussy out! I can't take it! Fuck! Ohhh!" She cried as more and more of the huge shaft of his penis slowly disappeared up inside her with each insistent thrust. She struggled, desperately trying to dislodge him; but to no avail.

"Fuck! Fuck! Oohhh! No! Ohhh! Fuck! Your cock is fucking massive! Ohh!" She cried, sounding panic stricken.

"It's massive... Oh my God! No, no, no! No! Oh fuck! Please go slow? Please go slow?" She cried out as he began pumping himself into her hard and fast, as she took ever more and more of him inside her.

"Oh Fuck! I can't do it. No, I can't do it! Please stop?" She was panting now with the exertion of it.

"Fuck! Stop! Please stop? Fuck! No? Fuck! Stop!" She was babbling; pleading in vain as Mike continued fucking her in earnest; pounding himself into her quite mercilessly. It was very noticeable that each time he withdrew his cock it was obviously coated in her creamy white vaginal juices!

Another camera panned out to show the look of horror on her boyfriend's face at what they were doing to her. But gagged and tied to the chair as he was, there was absolutely nothing he could do to help her.

The longer Mike fucked her the wetter she was getting and pretty soon there was a thick white ring of her pussy cream around the base of his cock as dribbles could be seen being milked from her! She was obviously taking the entire thing inside her now and despite her desperate protests she was clearly getting extremely aroused by it!

"She likes it man! Oh yeah she really loves my big cock!" Mike said to her boyfriend before looking back at her. "Don't you little girl?"

"No! You're hurting me! Oh God! Help me!" She moaned with a little struggle, but then there was a palpable difference in her as she eventually seemed to capitulate. All the fight had gone out of her; she finally seemed to be accepting the fact of her rape as readily as her pussy was accepting his cock. We could all see how she took the vast thickness of it, repeatedly disappearing right up inside her slim young body, the little pink lips of her pussy stretching so very wide around it.

She was panting heavily with the exertion of taking him; her cunt so slippery and wet we could all hear the loud wet slurping sounds as his giant cock rapidly pumped in and out. They were raping her on her parents bed, her leaking vagina causing a growing dark stain on the sheets.

For several minutes we watched her getting fucked like this as she moaned and whimpered, her breathing laboured with the effort.

"Your cock is too big!" She eventually moaned breathlessly, "Your cock is much too big for me!"

"Oh no!" She cried, as if surprised, after several more minutes of him fucking her. He kept on pounding himself into her and every so often she'd cry out;

"No!"

"No!"

"Yes!"

"Please?"

"Yes!"

"So fucking big! So fucking big!" She moaned. It was obvious by this stage that she'd become so aroused she couldn't help responding to it.

"It's too big! Oh God! Much too big! But it feels so good at the same time. I don't know what to do!"

"Fuck me! Yes! Yes! Yes! Fuck me!" She implored, her involuntary sexual arousal clearly getting the better of her! So it went on, with Avery intermittently crying out between the loud moans and gasps of pleasure!

"You're going to ruin me, you're stretching my pussy so much! Yes! Just don't stop! Ohhh!"

"Ohh! Fuck! Oh Christ, I fucking love it!"

"Oh God, fuck me! Fuck me!"

"Oohhh! Oh God! Please? Please?"

"Don't stop! Don't stop! Oh Fuck! You're going to make me come..."

"Fuck me! Fuck me! Make me come! Make me come on your huge fucking cock!" She implored him.

"Ohhh! Oohhh! Fuck me! Fuck me!" She sounded frantic, desperate even...

"Ohhh God! you're going to make me come on your huge fucking cock!" She cried desperately!

"I'm coming! I'm coming! I can't help it! Oh God! It's not my fault! It's not my fault!" She cried out, I imagine mostly for her boyfriend's benefit.

"Nooaaggh! Ohhh! Aaaaaghhh!" She cried out and convulsed with the intensity of her orgasm, obviously all too aware of Mike high-fiving his grinning buddies. We could only imagine the look on her boyfriend's face seeing her coming for another guy in this way.

"Oh Jesus Christ! Oh fuck! Stop! Stop!" She cried as he simply pounded away at her, allowing her no respite. Paying no heed to her cries with the intensity of the orgasm he'd just given her, he just kept pumping himself into her ever harder and faster.

"Christ slow down! Ohhh God! You're going to make me come again! Oohhh! No! Aaaaaghhh!" She cried, as once again she rapidly reached another spectacularly intense orgasm! Each time she was made to come they would high-five each other triumphantly and taunt her boyfriend; "I bet she's never come like that for you has she buddy? She really likes Mike's big cock; she's such a little slut!"

"Oh! Oh! Oh! No! Please? No more! Please I can't take it anymore!" She panted breathlessly once she'd recovered a little.

"You fucking love it!" Somebody else said.

"No!" She tried to protest.

"Your boyfriend can see you fucking love it, you're such a horny little slut!" Mike taunted her, then turning to his buddies said; "Bring him closer so he can get a really good look!"

They brought the poor young guy really close and while they held her legs even wider apart, forced him to watch close up as his girlfriend repeatedly took the whole of that gigantic cock deep inside her with every stroke! In between her orgasms we could all see how she still jerked and spasmed uncontrollably with the intense aftershocks!

"Look at the way she's creaming all over me! The dirty little bitch can't get enough can she?" By the wide eyed look on his face, her boyfriend was as shocked at the way Avery was responding to the guy as she looked ashamed of it. It was obvious from the intensity of her orgasms, the dribbles of her pussy juices and the fact that her parents sheets were completely saturated just how extraordinarily aroused she was!

Avery's eyes focused on him, panting, her face bright red with shame, as he was looking incredulously at her, alternately between the monster going in and out of her incredibly wet pussy and her face! The expression on his face seemed to be one of pained disbelief...

"I'm so, so sorry Danny." She said, "I can't help it! He's making me! Oh God! Please? You've got to believe me?"

Danny could only stare back at her with hurt in his eyes... while Avery came and came again!

"Please stop? Please stop?" Avery eventually gasped breathlessly once her 4th or 5th orgasm subsided a little. She'd been coming in such quick succession until then she'd barely had time to speak; certainly not coherently.

The men holding her down for Mike smiled at each other, evidently delighted at the prospect of making her come against her will for as long as they wanted. So it went on and after about an hour of Mike fucking her she'd come numerous times and was desperately begging them to stop;

"Ohhh! Christ! Please? How much longer are you going to fuck me? I can't take it. No! No! Oohhh God! Naaaghhh! Oghhhgod!"

"No! No! Oohhh fuck! No more! You're making me come so hard on your huge fucking cock! I can't take it! Please? Don't make me come again? Please?" She cried, all too obviously in vain.

"You better get used to it darling; there's no stopping this! We're all going to take turns with you just as soon as Big Mike's done!" One of the guys said and they all laughed at the look of horror on her face. She obviously hadn't contemplated that this was going to be a gang rape. Any more than she'd contemplated the shame of having the number of times she would come in the following 2 days read out in court. A fact that the defence counsel took great delight in pointing out in their attempts to portray it as a sex game that was entirely consensual. They claimed that she'd wanted her boyfriend to organise the whole scene to experience her gang bang fantasies for real.

Eventually Mike obviously ejaculated inside her, groaning out loud as he rammed himself into her as far as he could while Avery desperately cried out;

"No! No! Not in my pussy! No! Please?"

Despite the fact that she was obviously aware that he was doing it without a condom, pumping his seed into her, she helplessly came again herself!

Because Mike had taken so long, several of them had got their cocks out and been wanking at the sight of him fucking her. Several of them had already ejaculated over her, so her face and hair was absolutely covered in their semen!

As soon as Mike pulled his cock out of her dripping pussy a large amount of their fluids drooled out of her with each of her vaginal contractions. The sheets were completely saturated. Avery was panting, trying to get her breath back and recover a little. Her eyes were fixed on the jerking, still very hard penis that bobbed between her legs. She still looked shocked at the size of it despite having been fucked by it for well over an hour!

As soon as Mike was out the way another man took his place, ramming himself into her and fucking her furiously. He was pretty well endowed but not anywhere near as large as Mike, and pretty soon she was moaning and gasping as he too wrestled all self-control from her... They seemed to take great delight in making her have so many involuntary orgasms; as if each one was somehow a sign of her surrender to them. Maybe it was also to show her boyfriend that not only was her body theirs, but even her mind was too.

After some time of watching the footage the poor girl was being fucked like a ragdoll; grunting, gasping and groaning, she barely looked conscious aside from the paroxysms of her orgasms every few minutes. They mostly seemed to only hold her tightly during these violent convulsions, keeping her legs spread wide apart so whoever was inside her could fuck her without interruption.

The video evidence actually didn't help her case much, to the degree that the decision almost went against her. The girl was clearly heard many times urging them to fuck her, despite her obvious initial reluctance. It seems that neither she nor the prosecution counsel were aware the video existed until it was too late.

By the time we had watched several hours of footage of him and all the others pounding into her creaming, sopping wet pussy as she cried out repeatedly in orgasm, it was increasingly hard to think it was entirely nonconsensual. Even the female jurors had their doubts; how could any girl possibly come 114 times in 2 days without enjoying herself? It was only when we were reminded that her enjoying it is not the same as wanting it, that we could see the decision we needed to make with any clarity.

She told the court that they literally raped her the whole of that first night, only pausing for a short while to raid her parents fridge come daybreak. They all took turns with her again throughout the next day until she was finally allowed to sleep for a while the following night.

At some point one of the videos showed her sitting astride Mike, in the reverse cowgirl position. He was holding her arms behind her back, working her up and down upon his huge cock, trying to ram as much of himself up into her as far as he could.

She was facing Danny at this point, yet again affording him a view of his girlfriend, legs stretched wide apart, as her pussy repeatedly swallowed the whole of the guy's huge great cock, his big hairy balls slapping wetly against her clitoris!

Her little tits were jiggling with the buffeting she was taking, the small dark nipples stiffly erect. Hard as it was to believe, she seemed to be even wetter than before; each thrust of his cock causing a dribble of her secretions to be milked from her.

Danny had to watch her moaning and gasping, convulsing in orgasm time and time again as he raped her like that! She seemed unable to stop looking at her boyfriend throughout; gasping and moaning, open mouthed, the expression on her face was a mixture of total sexual bliss and shame faced embarrassment!

"No! No! No! No!" She moaned as she slid wetly up and down upon her rapist's cock.

"I'm sorry Danny, I'm so sorry..." She cried, shaking her head from side side as she was rapidly fucked to yet another orgasm;

"I don't want to do this for them; Oh God! Please? It's too big! I can't...I can't help it! He's making me, he's making me come! Oh no! Aaaghh! Oh shit! Agghh!"

At some point they must have tired of holding her because the later videos showed her firmly strapped down and being raped with various objects from her parents' bedroom; large lotion bottles and hairspray cans. They used several items from the kitchen and refrigerator; a squash, a very large eggplant and an empty 16oz Snapple bottle were all worked inside her and used to make her come repeatedly. Even during these videos she could be heard begging them to fuck her with whatever they were using when she was just about to orgasm.

There was another video where they all took turns working their entire fists inside her vagina and raping her like that, again causing her to experience extremely intense multiple orgasms. These seemed to last such a long time that she mostly only begged for them to stop making her come in the brief intervals that she wasn't actually doing so!

We could only imagine what it was like for her when, to her utter shame and humiliation, the defense made her watch herself being fist fucked and having a rapid succession of especially intense orgasms, each of which easily lasted well over a minute. Seeing herself writhing about upon their thrusting fists and crying out in ecstasy, with droplets of her pussy juices flicking everywhere, there was obviously no point denying the fact that she was experiencing very intense pleasure during it.

So when the time came for her cross examination, this was something the defence counsel seemed to take great pleasure in challenging her with;

"Isn't it true Miss Apshaw, that this whole thing was something you and your boyfriend had orchestrated? That having found out from Danny that his friend had an extraordinarily large penis, you wanted to try it? You had him invite him and his friends over for you to have a gang bang didn't you? To see what it would be like... Isn't that why you are clearly experiencing such great pleasure, even having multiple orgasms, because you quite obviously wanted them to do that to you?"

When this was put to her she obviously couldn't deny the pleasure she had experienced during it, but to her credit, in a very slow and measured voice she said;

"No! I know it looks bad. I know I came, but I didn't want it; they made me do it. I don't know why but I couldn't stop my body having orgasms; I really tried to stop myself but there was nothing I could do! I wouldn't have wanted that; my boyfriend was there for Christ sake! Watching me... watching me come for them! How do you think that makes me feel?"

"I thought that was the whole point Miss Apshaw? Because you clearly find it very exciting to have your boyfriend watching you having sex with other men; making out that it's against your will when all the time you are obviously loving it!" Said the defence lawyer.

"No!" She cries. "That's not true!"

"So much so that you had, how many orgasms?" He asked.

"I don't know...?" she said falteringly.

"I do, it was 114! We counted them... We counted 114 orgasms that were recorded on the videos. Who knows how many more you actually had?" he said smugly.

"And tell me Miss Apshaw, how many times did you come for Mike, the one with this enormous penis you claimed was far too big for you? He asked with a hint of sarcasm.

Avery just stared at him, looking terrified about what he was going to say; how much worse he could make her look...

"There's certainly a disproportionate amount of video of you having sex with him isn't there? Isn't that because you wanted sex with him especially, because of his very large penis?"

"No! He was raping me; I didn't have a choice!" Avery protested.

"I'll tell you how many times you came for him Miss Apshaw; 65 separate occasions that we could count! Over half the orgasms you experienced were with this man... it's quite obvious to me that you knew exactly what you wanted, and he gave it to you!"

Avery was bright red in the face.

"Tell me, in the whole time you have been with your boyfriend, how many times have you achieved a sexual climax with him?"

"I'd rather not say." She said, looking to her lawyer for support.

"Not once! Isn't that the truth Miss Apshaw? You have never had an orgasm with your boyfriend yet here you are with these apparent strangers having a ball! The only reason I can possibly see that happening is because you wanted it to!"

"No! That's not true!" Avery protested.

"So how many times did he have intercourse with you?" The defence counsel enquired.

"I'd guess about 14 or 15 time's. He took a long time though... much longer than the others." Avery said quietly.

"So although you're claiming it was nonconsensual, let me remind you how many times you can be heard saying the words 'Fuck me!' It was in the order of 30 times..." He paused for effect. "When one person says that to another, isn't that by definition the very essence of consent? You asked, no, in fact you demanded that he fucked you! And he obliged you, didn't he?"

"I don't know how many times I have to say it; he raped me! They all raped me!" She insisted, more loudly.

"So you keep saying Miss Apshaw... so, tell me... isn't it a little unusual for girls of your age to shave off all their pubic hair?"

Avery blushed as she looked at him. "I didn't shave it... Danny asked me to have a Brazilian wax".

"Has he ever asked you to do that before?

"No?" She seemed puzzled.

"But this time you went ahead and did that for him. Why?"

"I don't know; he asked me to..." she answered hesitantly.

"Just, what? The day before you are going to be putting yourself on display to all these men you have all your pubic hair removed... a bit of a coincidence wouldn't you say?"

Avery was looking ever more uncomfortable. " He asked me to!" She said. "I wanted to make him happy!"

"I'd say it was the actions of a girl who was wanting to have sex and you prepared yourself for just that, making yourself look like the actress's in the porn movies- in fact, just like the gang bang movies that were on your very own laptop Miss Apshaw!" He said with a flourish as he turned to us and paused for a moment. He was gauging our reaction.

"And in the scenes that we have seen where you were... how do I put this? Being pleasured by their hands? Are you aware of what this is known as in the pornography business Miss Apshaw?"

She shook her head.

"Punch fucking I believe is the term!" He said, getting up close and looking her in the eyes. " It's when the already pretty extreme sexual act called fisting gets taken to the next level and they use their clenched fist; like they did with you...!" he paused and looked back at us. "Pretty hard core for someone as sweet and innocent as she would have us believe wouldn't you agree? I doubt whether many women could even manage that, let alone enjoy it! Yet every one of the accused did that with her and the only complaint she had to make about it was what? That they were making her come too much! My wife would be so lucky!"

"Objection!" Called the prosecution QC.

"Sustained." Said the judge.

"Let me put it to you Miss Apshaw that it was your fantasy that was being acted out here? You wanted it to be a make believe rape scene, because you suspected; hoped even, that these men would give you the kind of pleasure that your boyfriend wasn't giving you?"

"No, that's not true, I love Danny! He loves me!" She said, almost petulantly.

"And I suppose that's why he's not here in court isn't it? To support you..." He said sarcastically.

"He's mad at me..." She said quietly.

"Speak up Miss Apshaw"

"He's mad at me!" She said more loudly.

"Why Miss Apshaw? Why is he mad at you?"

"Because I came for them... because I came for all of them!" She almost whispered... and her eyes welled up with tears.

"That's right isn't it? Because you were enjoying it just a little too much! Because you came for them! We could all see how you started off pretending not to like it, obviously to complete your little rape fantasy, but then you are clearly heard saying that you loved it and begging them to fuck you!" The defence counsel said. "It was only when you saw the look on your boyfriend's face that you realised you were enjoying yourself a little too much! And that's why you cried rape, so that 'Miss butter wouldn't melt in her mouth' can claim none of it was her fault!"

"No!" She retorted.

"That will be all your honour." He concluded.

Eventually the prosecution called in their expert medical witness, a serious looking Australian woman in her forties, Dr Mattock. She was consultant gynaecologist and had many years of experience in rape/ trauma work both in Australia and the UK. In my experience, like many in her profession, she seemed to be a little on the Autistic spectrum; very black and white. No doubt she was extremely good at her work but perhaps lacking in people skills and quite evidently not so good at recognising others emotional states.

Avery had to sit and listen as the very copious amounts of her vaginal secretions were discussed back and forth, again with the defence counsel pointing out the video evidence of the dribbles of it running down the shaft of Mike's huge cock.

But much as the defence tried to shame her, Dr Mattock's view was that this had saved her from some quite serious injuries that could otherwise have occurred. To her credit she explained that the body has mechanisms to limit injury and to my surprise it is especially likely to happen the longer the assault goes on. As she explained it's therefore much more likely to become apparent during a lengthy gang rape than a solo act of rape.

At this point she turned to Avery and said; "Come here young lady; this is really important for you to understand." She waited until Avery could see the TV screen we were looking at and went on to explain that, with her rather youthful anatomy 'down there' and the combination of prolonged stimulation by an organ of such exceptional thickness it was highly likely to lead to her experiencing orgasm.

She then had them play one of the videos of Avery impaled on her rapist's cock in slow motion and pointed out what was happening to her clitoris. I could see the abject shame of the poor girl as we were all shown her genitals in close up as his gigantic cock went in and out of her in slow motion...

It was already obvious that each time he went into her that her pussy lips were being stretched really tight; so much so that her clitoris was being pulled against the shaft of his cock, but Dr Mattock further explained;

"If you observe here..." She said, pointing at Averys clitoris, you will see that the inner labia are so stretched by the girth of the penis that the head of her clitoris has been forced out of the clitoral hood and it's being pressed against the penile shaft. You see how it pops out of its protective sheath; the clitoral hood, with each thrust?" She asked, turning to Avery as we focused on the TV screen.

I hadn't noticed before but it was true; the tip of the little engorged nub was being forced out from its protective hood and being rubbed against the guys shaft with each inward thrust! It seemed as if each time he went into her the thickness of his cock was forcing it to bulge out of her! It reminded me of those rubbery children's toy monsters when you squeeze them and the eyes pop out!

And if it wasn't already bad enough for the young girl that her genitals were splayed out wide in front of us but even the most private part, the very nub of her pleasure, was being forced out of her, bulging out for all of us to see!

Dr Mattock seemed completely oblivious to the fact that she was causing so much embarrassment to the poor girl; talking about the most intimate parts of her body and her sexual responses to the rape as if she was talking about some kind of fascinating case study.

Later, changing the video to show one of Avery with the Snapple bottle inside her; she fast forwarded it to a point where she'd just come and the bottle had just been left inside her as she lay there, strapped down and panting heavily.

She pointed to Avery's clitoris again; "See here, you will observe that the clitoris has been completely popped; it's now so engorged with blood that it can't retract into the prepuce anymore!" She explained, almost excitedly. "Watch what happens now." she said, turning back to the screen.

The bottle was jerking slightly with her vaginal contractions and ever so slowly it began slipping out of Avery's vagina. Eventually it fell out of her onto the bed. Now that her pussy was empty, we could see the vaginal orifice gaping slightly and her inner labia looked slightly oedematous; swollen and inflamed, no doubt from all the friction.

"You will observe how the clitoral glans remains totally exposed now, despite the vagina being empty? I have seen this before; if the clitoral hood is a little tight, when extremely aroused the clitoris can become so engorged with blood that it cannot retract. It becomes quite literally stuck; popped out of her like this. When this happens, once someone is already highly aroused, any friction will produce tremendous stimulation to the super sensitive tip of the clitoris; it would be almost impossible for any woman to resist orgasm with that kind of stimulation." She continued, addressing the rest of us. "In my professional opinion it was almost inevitable with all this happening that she was going to be forced to orgasm, regardless of whether she wanted to."

She asked for another video to be shown; the one showing Avery being fucked by that huge cock as she sat astride Mike. Again it was shown in slow motion. "Now you can see she is fully popped; the clitoris does not retract at all now." She said. "She's unable to stop herself being intensely stimulated the whole time, not only by the shaft of his penis but also by the testicles as they slap against her clitoris."

As the video continued Mike pulled her back down onto his chest, both of them panting loudly as he held her down on top of him, taking a moment to rest. Averys breasts were heaving and she was shiny with sweat. The guy called Pete walked into frame, staring between her legs.

"Hey guys, look here!" He pointed to her pussy. "The little man in the boat has come out to play!" Avery struggled as they crowded around; I imagine she was wondering what they were looking at.

Her clitoris looked like it was just about fit to burst, it was so engorged and rigid. The others came over and watched Pete reach out and squeeze the slippery little protuberance. .. Avery squirmed, writhing about upon the cock inside her and cried out; "No!"

But Pete simply smiled and continued to manipulate her clit, rubbing her wetness in circles around the tip. Mike held onto her tightly as she wriggled with the intensity of the new sensation.

"Oh Christ! Oh Christ! You're going to make me, Oh Fuck! Aaghhh! No! OhhhhGod!" She cried out in another incredibly intense orgasm.

Pete wouldn't let up and pretty soon Mike started fucking her again. Avery came several more times like this until they brought Danny to her and he was made to lick and suck her little bulging clitoris while her eyes rolled in ecstasy. But it soon became obvious that it wasn't for her pleasure that they forced him to do that. Within a couple of minutes Mike could be heard coming as he rammed himself into her.

"Don't fucking stop Danny boy, keep licking!" Mike told him as thick dribbles of his sperm emerged from Avery's pussy. "Eat my come from her cunt!"

And as he did Avery came yet again! I did wonder if she was actually getting off on the humiliation of her boyfriend at this point.

Dr Mattock had been watching this with a glazed look in her eyes but at this point she turned back to us and continued; "Most women prefer less direct stimulation of the clitoris if the glans is exposed like this but when she has no choice... This is why we see such extraordinary amounts of sexual fluids being produced by her body and the excruciatingly intense orgasm's she experienced!" She says, then turning to address Avery "In some cases this popping of the clitoris will spontaneously resolve within a short time once the stimulation stops..."

Once again Avery blushed bright red; looking acutely embarrassed as she stared at Dr Mattock like a frightened deer before interrupting her;

"I think they've broken me down there... I can't... It's not like I was before, " She whispered. "It's still poking out!"

Dr Mattock smiled. "I have seen your medical photography and I could see that the hood was still retracted. That's perfectly normal Avery; some women are naturally made that way. From what I have seen your clitoral hood is relatively short and I suspect you have a slight degree of phimosis; it's like a boy having a tight foreskin. Given your anatomy, normally your clitoris would have slowly extended out around puberty. The slightly tight clitoral hood would have prevented that from happening at that point. Essentially what happened has simply released it; there's absolutely nothing to worry about, it's perfectly healthy."

Dr Mattock also pointed out that even without her protruding clitoris, once Avery had been made to orgasm a few times; because they wouldn't stop and held her open to be persistently stimulated it was pretty much inevitable that she would have to keep experiencing these involuntary orgasms anyway.

"I know it's a little embarrassing but what I'm saying is it that you did nothing wrong my dear." She smiled as she explained to Avery. "You were absolutely right; it wasn't your fault. They did make you experience involuntary orgasms because your perfectly healthy body was doing what it's designed to do... and as I've explained; almost every woman under these circumstances would have."

Then finally turning to the court she said;

"If any of you don't believe in involuntary sexual arousal let me remind you that you have all witnessed the brutal gang rape of this girl and I'll guarantee each and every one of you has been sexually aroused by it!" She challenged. "If you want to deny that, come see me at the end of the day. A quick swab of your underwear will prove you to be entirely wrong!"

Not a single person took her up on her challenge. I certainly wouldn't have; I'd been wearing super duty pantie liners since the first day of the trial because I was ending up so wet! I had been feeling ashamed of myself but it seems like all of our responses were both normal and involuntary; which was exactly the point she was making.

Dr Mattock told the court that the fact that she'd orgasmed so many times was a protective factor for her, because despite the extensive abuse, apparently she'd suffered no physical injuries. Apparently because she'd kept orgasming her vagina continued to produce a lot of lubrication throughout the whole of her ordeal.

I found these explanations really helpful to understand why this happened to her and I imagine it must have been helpful to the poor girl. It can't have been easy for her; thinking that she must have wanted it because she came for them.

The final bombshell in the case was that it turned out that Danny had in fact invited the gang to her parents' house, just as the defence had claimed. It turned out that he'd recently gotten involved with this gang and felt too scared to say no when Mike had invited them all over to 'party' with his girlfriend.

The gang members claimed that Danny had heard about Mike's large penis and that Avery was so hot for it she asked him to invite them all over to 'party' with her.

Apparently Danny was so unwilling to give evidence that he was held in contempt of court and sent to prison during the court case. From what we were given to believe he had since abandoned her; cutting off all contact with Avery immediately after her rape.

Of course the crucial question then became whether she knew this was going to happen, and whether she'd agreed to it. The defence argued that her boyfriend had organised it with her agreement because she had told him she really liked the idea of a gang bang and 'wanted to put on a show for him.'

It was an extremely difficult decision but in the end we did unanimously find the gang guilty of her rape. In truth there was some degree of reasonable doubt. There was evidence to suggest that she at least knew that some of Danny's gang were coming over to 'party' with her. Apparently there were some porn videos found on her laptop featuring very similar scenarios to what happened to her. The defence argued that this was a clear indication of her wish to indulge in that kind of sex.

Despite the likelihood that she and (more likely) her boyfriend had organised for it to happen I believe our decision was mostly based upon the fact that she became so exhausted by the constant orgasms that she was desperately begging them to stop. The fact that they simply carried on regardless and continued over the course of the whole weekend was what really went against them. As the prosecution pointed out; 'No means no at whatever point in the proceedings it takes place.'

Despite that, even the women of the jury agreed that it was probably better for her that she'd come so much; knowing just how terribly sore she would have been without the lubrication caused by the extreme level of arousal she'd experienced.