How about that, for once I'm updating about my reading on a Wednesday! My current project is to go through my physical TBR pile and sort into keep/donate. This project is slightly more perilous than I originally envisioned, since I read while nursing J and I worry about dropping hardcovers on his wee head. (I have not actually dropped a book on my child, don't worry.) I am not done yet, but here are the results thus far!
1)
Almost Like Being in Love by Steve Kluger. Travis and Craig fall in love in high school, then drift apart. Twenty years later, Travis, an incurable romantic, realizes that Craig is the great love of his life. He just doesn't know how to get in touch with him. Or that Craig has a long-term partner. A light-hearted contemporary M/M romance told via letters, journal entries, answers to bonus questions on quizzes, court transcripts, and other miscellany. This novel somehow pulls off some romance tropes I hate, like "every secondary and tertiary character is invested in The Romance" and "let's aggressively pair off every single adult." Something about the humor and the leads' great love of musicals make my brain relax and go, "Okay, heightened reality rules are at play here." Kudos to the novel for making The Other Man a great guy, and his relationship with Craig strained because of understandable differences. I genuinely did not know how the romantic storyline was going to resolve. One caveat: there are some lines that have not aged well since 2004.
Verdict:
Keep. I can see myself packing it for a nice beach reread, or lending it to someone else. Helps that it's a paperback and doesn't take up much space. Would consider buying as an ebook if I need more bookshelf space, though.
2)
Pet by Akwaeke Emezi. Jam is a teenage girl growing up in a post-revolution utopia. One generation ago, "angels" (revolutionaries) fought and eradicated all the "monsters" (corrupt cops, rapists, etc.) as well as the systems that propped them up. When Jam accidentally brings one of her mother's paintings to life, she discovers that there's a monster loose in her hometown. The writing is lyrical, and I love that Jam is a Black trans girl, but her narrative is about catching the monster. The identity of the "monster" is easy to guess, and the whole angel/monster metaphor is massively oversimplified. That said, I am not the intended audience of a YA book! That ALSO being said, I feel very hmm about the single line that mentions eliminating all religion as part of what makes the utopia a utopia. Hmm!
( Also, an excellent point I read in a review on the type of plot twist this book employs. Cut for spoilers, even though it's pretty easy to figure out. )Verdict:
Discard. I'm not the intended audience for this book, and too much of it is too oversimplified for me. I would rather it go to my local library, where it has a better chance of finding its reader(s).
3)
Provenance by Ann Leckie. A standalone novel set in the Imperial Radch universe! Ingray is the adopted child of a politician. Her brother is the favorite to inherit the family name, so naturally her solution is to spring a criminal out of prison and recruit them to steal back the priceless artifact they originally stole. Despite Ingray's intentions at the beginning, this novel is not a heist! There is a murder, but the novel is much more interested in asking questions about incarceration, heritage, and cultural artifacts than whodunnit! The cultural artifacts, murder, and Ingray all end up at the center of an escalating interstellar conflict, so there are some exciting hostage scenes as well. I liked this book well enough, but I think it tried to do far too much and subsequently didn't do any of its big ideas full justice. Also, the premise of SPACE HEIST is too tantalizing to abandon in a satisfactory way!
( One other minor, spoilery disappointment. )Verdict:
Discard. I liked the experience of reading the book well enough, but I'm overall lukewarm on it. (Also, having it in hardcover means it takes up a lot of space on my bookshelf.) If I ever want to reread it, I don't have any big concerns about being able to find Ann Leckie books in ebook format.
...I also totally broke the rules and read two library holds when they came in, but I have run out of time for this entry!