"I've played old men since the age of 18."
You know how sometimes you're watching a show and you think, "Hey, isn't that person too young to be a doctor?" This is an example of under-aged casting, and it happens when an actor is far too young for the character that they're portraying. For example, a 22-year-old actor is playing a character who's said to have a doctorate degree; unless they were some kind of teenage prodigy, they would be in their late 20s at the absolute youngest, and if they're experienced and respected in their field, mid-30s.
This happens most frequently to characters who are doctors, lawyers or some other profession that requires several years of graduate/professional school, though this trope can be justified if the character is said to have skipped grades to get where they are.
Thanks to Hollywood double standards against middle-aged actresses, younger women tend to be cast in older roles more often than men.
It is not simply the opposite of Dawson Casting, because it doesn't only require that the actor is younger than the character. The actor must be too young to logically fill the character's role themselves.
Sometimes applies when the character being played is extremely elderly, such that an actor of equal age, if not retired, would be too physically frail to endure the rigors of a demanding production schedule.
See also Improbable Age.
Contrast with Age Lift, which is when the Adaptation of another work changes the Age of a Character compared to the Source Material.
Examples:
open/close all folders
Live-Action TV
- An in-universe example happens in the Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. episode "T.R.A.C.K.S": Coulson and Simmons are under cover as a father/daughter couple. Simmons, who is in her mid twenties, remarks that Coulson (in his late forties) is much too young to have a daughter her age (he isn't, but she was mostly just saying it to make him feel better about the ruse).
- Rose Hill played Edith's bedridden old mother Madame Fanny in 'Allo 'Allo! yet was only seven years older than her on-screen daughter Carmen Silvera. As Hill was almost always hidden underneath blankets and a baggy nightdress, it helped sell the illusion to the audience.
- Are You Being Served?:
- Nicholas Smith (Mr. Rumbold) played the part of a middle manager who had served in World War II, but he was in reality only five months older than Trevor Bannister (Mr. Lucas), who portrayed a junior who had been at school during the War.
- Larry Martyn was 38 when the series began but was made up to look older as Mr. Mash with greying hair and a false moustache, presumably to add credibility to the character being a union head. Furthermore, Mash was mentioned to have been fighting in World War II during D-Day in "Cold Store" — Martyn was only ten when the Allied forces made it to Normandy.
- Old Mr. Grace was played by Kenneth Waller, age 54; his younger brother was played by Harold Bennett, who was 28 years older.
- In "Founder's Day" and "Heir Apparent", John Inman doubled as Annie Humphries, his own character's mother!
- Auf Wiedersehen, Pet: While Dennis was ten years older than Neville, he was played by Tim Healy, who was actually a year younger than Kevin Whately.
- Barry: Robert Wisdom plays Janice Moss's father Jim, but he and Paula Newsome are only 9 years apart in age.
- The fictional Prime Minister Michael Callow in the first episode of Black Mirror was played by Rory Kinnear, 33 at the time. Not as improbable as some other examples, but the youngest British Prime Minister in the last century was 42 when he assumed office.
- The Boys and Gen V: Claudia Doumit was 30 years old while filming the first season of Gen V, when her character is in the middle of a vice presidential campaign. In the United States, vice presidents must be at least 35 years of age. Amusingly, Doumit is only two years older than Jaz Sinclair, who plays a college freshman.
- Cobra Kai:
- Da-Eun's grandfather Master Kim, who trained her, as well as Kreese and Silver, has been a Tang Soo Do master since at least the Korean War. He's still alive in the present day, played by an aged-up C.S. Lee, who is in his early 50s. His already being a master by 1950 realistically puts his age at well over 100.
- Dad's Army:
- Corporal Jones was in his late seventies at the very least but was played by Clive Dunn who was only 48 when the series started. Meaning that, ironically, the oldest member of the platoon was played by one of the youngest members of the cast.
- The plot of "All is Safely Gathered In" kicks off when Godfrey wants to go help his old flame, Mrs. Prentice, gather her harvest. Despite the fact that Mrs. Prentice is supposed to be of a similar age to dear old Godfrey, Brenda Cowling was only 47 at the time, while Arnold Ridley was 76!
- In Family Matters, Darius McCrary (Eddie) was only 13 in the first season but was playing a high school freshman. And even though Eddie was the eldest of the Winslow children, McCrary is actually a month younger than his "little" sister Laura's actress Kellie Shanygne Williams. The reason he got away with it is because McCrary was very tall as a boy, already as tall as his onscreen father Carl in the first season. By the time the show ended with Eddie as an adult, McCrary was 6'3 and towered over his castmates.
- General Hospital: Jason Thompson plays Patrick Drake, a well-known neurosurgeon, despite the fact that he premiered in 2005 when he was 29 years old...which is a few years younger than the average age of most attending physicians. Similarly, Kimberly McCullogh returned as Robin Scorpio at roughly the same time as an attending, though she (and her character) were 27 at the time, which meant that she would have been more likely to be a resident.
- In Episodes, then 28-Year-Old Mircea Monroe portraying the very much aged (possibly 40s or 50s) actress Morning Randolph, who was said to have plastic surgeries to stay young.
- The Golden Girls: Estelle Getty was 62 when she started playing Sophia, the 80-year-old mother of Dorothy, and was actually younger than her onscreen daughter Bea Arthur. That being said, reports of Getty being the "second-youngest" of the Golden Girls are greatly overstated. She and Arthur were only 18 months apart with Betty White in between, whereas Rue McClanahan was over 10 years younger than the others.
- Grotesquerie: Nicholas Alexander Chavez was 24 when he played an ER doctor apparently left in charge of a long-comatose woman; Micaela Diamond was also 24 when she played a detective who's been competing for Lois's job for a while.
- The Haunting of Bly Manor strangely casts the 26-year-old Alex Essoe as Charlotte, mother of Miles and Flora (who are twelve and eight respectively). Married to a man twenty years older than her, and having an affair with his similar in age brother, she comes across as wildly too young for the character; acting with a wise, motherly presence that suggests she's meant to be in her late thirties. Contrast with Victoria Pedretti, who's the same age, playing a character who was only recently about to get married.
- This was inevitable in Home Movie: The Princess Bride with how much Colorblind Casting is in this production; most instances are actors' clearly too-young children either Fake Shemping or playing characters that are adults in the original, with no attempt to make them look older. Like everything else, it's Played for Laughs.
- During Tom Lennon's turn as Humperdinck, his son Oliver, eleven years old at the time of the shooting, plays Count Rugen in the early search for Buttercup.
- For Patton Oswalt's turn as Vizzini during the Battle of Wits, his daughter Alice, eleven years old at the time of shooting, plays Buttercup.
- At 50, Sarah Silverman is the youngest of the actors to play the Grandfather. She wears a silver wig, graying bushy mustache and eyebrows, and a suit, and puts on something like an exaggerated East Coast or Philly accent ("Yes, you're very smaht."). Never mind that unless some people were having kids very young, fifty is pretty young to have an eleven-year-old grandchild, and makeup aside, she doesn't look fifty, anyway.
- House: Real doctors (not including Doogie Howser, M.D.) usually graduate from medical school in their mid-20s, and at that point they've still got years of residency ahead before they can do the kinds of jobs the characters on the show do. When their respective characters joined the cast, Olivia Wilde was 23, Jesse Spencer and Lo Mutuc were 25, and Odette Annable was 26.
- House of the Dragon:
- Olivia Cooke was 28 when she first appeared as adult Alicent Hightower. Before the show jumped six years into the future in episode 8, her casting makes sense in-universe, as Alicent is a teenage mom and her eldest child, Aegon, is 13 years old (though played by a 19-year-old actor). After the time jump, however, she just looks far too young to be the mother of four young adult children. As the show continues, the age gap between Cooke and Alicent reduces. However, this just makes the Dawson Casting of her children all the more noticeable.
- To a lesser extent, Emma D'Arcy, who was 29 when they first appeared as adult Rhaenyra Targaryen. They continued to portray Rhaenyra after the timeskip in episode 8, in which her eldest son, Jacaerys, is 16 years old, even though it's been established that she had him when she was 18.
- How I Met Your Mother: Robin (born 1980) is the youngest character of the main cast but she still actually a couple of years older than Cobie Smulders (born 1982) is in real life, presumably to shift her being a news anchor out of Improbable Age territory.
- I Love Lucy: One of the most famous examples is Vivian Vance playing Ethel Mertz. While Ethel's age is never explicitly given, it's heavily implied that the Mertzes are a significantly older couple than the Ricardos. In reality, Vance was only two years older than Lucile Ball and 22 years younger than William Frawly playing her husband. Vance was annoyed at being presented as an old lady.
- Kamen Rider BLACK SUN: Hidetoshi Nishijima played 80 something years old Kotaro Minami and Nishijima is 51 years old. Tomoya Nakamura also played 80 something years old Nobuhiko Akizuki and Nakamura is 35 years old.
- Man About the House: George and Mildred were engaged during World War II, whereas Brian Murphy was only 12 by the end of the war.
- On Miami Vice, Helena Bonham Carter was twenty when she played a doctor who was supposed to be about thirty. At the time, she looked like she was twelve.
- Mid-Century Modern: Jerry is played by Matt Bomer who was 47 while filming the first season, but Jerry is at least 50 based on the timeline we're given of his life. He started sleeping around on Fire Island where he met Bunny, Arthur, and George 30 years prior to the start of the series, and he was already a divorced father and exiled from his Mormon church by then. Bomer would have been a teenager at the time, but it's extremely unlikely that Jerry was any younger than early 20's. Since part of Jerry's character is how frustratingly good-looking he is despite his age, casting a younger actor was likely a deliberate choice.
- Moon Lovers: Averted when Ha-jin first arrives in the past, since the characters are roughly the same age as their actors, but played straight later. Ha-jin spends at least twenty years in the past, but virtually no one visibly ages during that time. Reaches ridiculous levels in the epilogue, which takes place several years after Ha-jin's death but shows Baek-ah and Wang So looking exactly the same as they did over twenty years earlier.
- Neighbours:
- Alan Dale, who played Paul Robinson's father Jim, is only 11 years older than Stefan Dennis in real life. Overlaps with Dawson Casting, as Dennis is about six years older than Paul was meant to be.
- Nick Waters was only 34 when he played Fred Mitchell, several years younger than Anne Charleston as his estranged wife Madge, making him about 14 when he would have married her and not much older when their children Henry and Charlene were born.
- Shane Connor (b.1959) and Carla Bonner (b.1973) played Joe Scully and his daughter Stephanie. Again overlaps with Dawson Casting in Stephanie's case.
- Andrew McFarlane played Max Hoyland's father Bobby, despite being only 13 years older than Stephen Lovatt. He was also ten years younger than his ex-wife Rosie's actor Maggie Millar.
- The Newsroom: Olivia Munn was 29 years old when she started shooting Season One when the character is supposed to have two PhDs and several years of real-world experience beside, before the start of the show, making her character at least a few years older than her actual age.
- NOS4A2: Vic's parents in the series are played by actors only eleven and fourteen years older than her actor, respectively (though of course, Vic's actor is significantly older than her character).
- Only Murders in the Building: Mandy Gonzalez, who plays Mabel's mother Silvia, is only fourteen years older than her onscreen daughter Selena Gomez in real life. For an additional Double Standard, Mark Consuelos plays Mabel's father in flashbacks to when she is around twelve, and would have been in his late 40s or early 50s at the time.
- On the House: Old Fred (over 60) was played by John Normington (33 when the series began) caked in old man makeup. This stood out even more as his costars were Kenneth Connor (52), John Junkin (40), Tommy Godfrey (54), and Gordon Rollings (44).
- The majority of Power Rangers teams are high school students (played by 20-somethings), but the occasional season will have a team of rangers with other professions that require extensive training still played by the typical 18-25 actors they always have. Dana Mitchell of Power Rangers Lightspeed Rescue was a paramedic played by 20-year-old Allison McInnis, who was then a full-fledged pediatrician the next year. Dana's older brother Ryan played by Rhett Fisher is same age as McInnis and Captain Mitchell Dana and Ryan's father is played by Ron Rogee is only twelve years older. Similarly, by the time of Dino Thunder, Tommy Oliver (then-31-year-old-Jason David Frank) had finished college, gotten a Doctorate in Palaeontology, and developed the Dino Thunder technology, all in the six-year span since he graduated high school midway through Turbo. Power Rangers in Space, Astronema/Karone is younger sister of Andros but Melody Perkins is 4 years older than Christopher Khayman Lee. Power Rangers Lost Galaxy, Mike Corbett is older brother of Leo Corbett but Mike's actor Russell Laurence is 5 years younger than Leo's actor Danny Slavin.
- Red Dwarf: Hattie Hayridge's first role in the series was in "Parallel Universe" as Hilly, the exact female opposite of Norman Lovett's Holly. Despite this, Hayridge was thirteen years younger than Lovett and looked it, too.
- Jennifer Robertson played the mother of Tim Rozon's character on Schitt's Creek, despite being only five years older than him. Rozon was perhaps playing a few years younger than his actual age, and Jocelyn was said to have been a teen mother, but this was still pushing it. It made for a very effective gag where Alexis sees the two of them together and thinks they're involved.
- Lynne Frederick was 22 when she played Shermeen Williams in the Space: 1999 episode "A Matter of Balance". If we assume that Shermeen is the same age as the actress, this means she would have been only a teenager at the time of the accident that launched the moon out of Earth orbit.
- The Stand (1994) cast 71-year-old Ruby Dee as 106-year-old Abagail Freemantle with heavy makeup. She wasn't even the oldest member of the cast; Ossie Davis was five years older despite his character (Judge Farris) being much younger. This is probably excusable by the simple lack of suitable actresses who were still active at anywhere near Mother Abagail's canonical age.
- Steptoe and Son: Wilfrid Brambell was only 49 when he began playing Albert Steptoe, who was supposed to be 63 when the series began; he was just 13 years older than his on-screen son, Harry H. Corbett.
- Part of the Tragic Backstory of Strike Back's Colonel Alexander Coltrane is an especially traumatic mission in the Balkans in 1992. He explicitly stated that he was a lieutenant, but at that time, his portrayer, Jamie Bamber, would have been only 19 and would have been extremely unlikely to be ranked that high.
- Strong Medicine's Dr. Lu Delgado is a full-fledged physician even though her actress Rosa Blasi was only 27 when the show premiered. At that age, she'd still be in her residency, not practicing on her own.
- Till Death Us Do Part:
- Warren Mitchell was less than ten years older than his on-screen daughter Una Stubbs and son-in-law Anthony Booth.
- Joan Sims played toothless old Gran yet was only younger than her on-screen daughter Dandy Nichols by just over twenty years. The old lady makeup and clothes helped sell the belief significantly.
- VR Troopers: Dave Carr (born 1966), who plays Dr. Tyler Steele, is only ten years older than Brad Hawkins (born 1976), who plays his son and show protagonist Ryan Steele. Initially Carr was only used for the opening flashbacks of every episode where Tyler would impart his wisdom to a child version of Ryan played by a different actor, but the story of the show eventually forced Tyler to interact with the present-day adult version of his son.
- Ultraman Gaia has one episode mention that it’s Georgie’s 20th Birthday. Maria Theresa Gow was only 16 during production of the show.
- The Vampire Diaries: David Anders is only 8 years older than Nina Dobrev, who plays his daughter. Though, his receding hairline does make him look older than he actually his.
- Also Elena and Jeremy's aunt is supposed to be in her late 20s but Sara Canning was 22 at the start of the series while her niece and nephew were played actors only 1-2 years younger than she.
- You Rang, M'Lord?: Paul Shane and Su Pollard played father and daughter but were only nine years apart in age.
- Gillian Anderson was cast as Dana Scully on The X-Files at 24, though she lied and said she was 27 to make her seem more believable as an FBI agent with a medical degree; her character is 28 at the start of the series. A combination of Under Age Casting and Improbable Age for the character make for noticeable dissonance. Scully is a teacher at Quantico and a forensic pathologist, a career which requires 13-15 years of education. This is in addition to the two years she is stated to have been with the FBI in the pilot. Scully should be at least in her mid-30s in the pilot.
Music
- AOA: A good chunk of the dance unit members in the "Short Hair" MV (police woman, Scar mechanic, air stewardess), it's all in good fun.
Pro Wrestling
- Tommaso Ciampa's Early-Bird Cameo in WWE had him playing a corporate lawyer at the age of 20.
Radio
- Dead Ringers: That Time had Sue Johnston play Sean Bean's mum when she's only fifteen years older than him is pointed out in one sketch where she breaks character to wonder about this.
Sue Johnston: We were married in a Morse, for Pete's sake!
- The Navy Lark:
- Tenniel Evans was 33 when the series began but played much older characters, including Pertwee's grizzled uncle Nunkie and the hard-of-hearing Admiral.
- Ronnie Barker was only 30 when he was cast as Scatterbrained Senior Lieutenant Commander Stanton.
- Michael Bates was 40 when he first played the dithering fool Rear Admiral Ironbridge (who gives his age as 72 in "The Security Clampdown") and 42 when he first played the kindly old Padre.
